Skip to content
PaperFren

Creativity

Does being mindful help or hurt creative problem solving?

Zedelius CM, Schooler JW · Frontiers in psychology · 2015

Open access · cc by · source: Europe PMC

People high in trait mindfulness solved word puzzles better when they worked them out step by step, but not when they relied on a sudden 'aha', and overall they solved fewer puzzles.

How this study connects

Role on claims

Each row is a claim on a concept or method page where this paper supports, challenges, or qualifies the statement. Roles are hand-checked — not a model guess.

Not yet placed on a claim. This paper has study layers, but no concept page yet cites it as support, challenge, or qualifier.

Study at a glance

Design
Human experiment — Study 1: correlational, trial-by-trial self-reports of insight vs. strategy; Study 2: instructions to use insight or analytic strategy manipulated within participants, plus a no-instruction control group
N
Two separate MTurk samples: 70 analysed in Study 1 and 99 analysed in Study 2, split between a no-instruction control group and an instruction group
Population
US adults recruited through Amazon Mechanical Turk
Outcome
Accuracy, commission errors and omission errors on compound remote associates (CRA) problems, predicted from trait mindfulness (MAAS)

Structured fields used in claim comparison tables when every cited study has a complete layer.

Inspect source passages

Does being mindful help or hurt creative problem solving?

These passages occur verbatim in the stored paper text. They support the points listed below; they do not verify every statement in the explanation.

70 participants were analysed in Study 1

Of the 70 participants included in the analysis, 15 failed to complete the demographic questions.

99 participants were analysed in Study 2

Twenty-one participants were removed for that reason, leaving 99 participants in the analyses (42 male, 57 female, average age = 38 years, SD = 12).
Read passages in the original paper

Key findings

In Study 1, higher mindfulness predicted lower overall accuracy, driven by more wrong answers. On puzzles people said they solved purely by insight, more mindful people did worse, whereas on puzzles solved purely by strategy they did better. In Study 2, mindfulness again predicted lower accuracy without instructions and higher accuracy under analytic instructions, but it was unrelated to accuracy under insight instructions. The instructions themselves did not change average accuracy, which was the same in both instructed blocks.

Methodology

Across two online studies, adults solved compound remote associates problems, where three words (such as board, magic, death) all combine with one hidden fourth word, and then completed a mindful attention questionnaire. In Study 1 (70 analysed participants), people rated after each of 30 puzzles whether they had solved it through systematic strategy or sudden insight. In Study 2 (99 analysed participants), people either got no instructions or were told to use an insight approach in one block and an analytic search in the other, over 48 puzzles.

Limitations

Mindfulness was only measured as a self-reported trait, so a third variable such as working memory could explain the links, and the study cannot say whether mindfulness training would have the same effects. Study 1 classified problem-solving style from people's own after-the-fact reports, and Study 2's insight instructions were probably hard to follow, which may explain why the insight result did not replicate. The error-pattern findings also differed between the two studies. Samples were online volunteers, with several dropped for solving no puzzles at all.

Related papers in this topic

Same topic cluster — not a recommendation engine.