Skip to content
PaperFren

Bilingualism

Does being better in a second language help you monitor mistakes?

Singh N, Mishra RK · Frontiers in psychology · 2014

Open access · cc by · source: Europe PMC

Bilinguals who were more proficient in their second language slowed down more after conflicts and errors, suggesting better self-monitoring, but they were not clearly better at stopping an action.

How this study connects

Role on claims

Each row is a claim on a concept or method page where this paper supports, challenges, or qualifies the statement. Roles are hand-checked — not a model guess.

Not yet placed on a claim. This paper has study layers, but no concept page yet cites it as support, challenge, or qualifier.

Study at a glance

Design
Cross-sectional — Quasi-experimental group comparison (high vs low English proficiency, grouped by school medium) on a visually guided (Exp 1) and memory guided (Exp 2) saccadic redirect task with eye tracking.
N
Two separate samples: 47 bilinguals in Experiment 1 (22 high, 25 low proficiency) and 38 in Experiment 2 (18 high, 20 low).
Population
Hindi-English bilingual university students in Allahabad, India, matched on non-verbal IQ and SES
Outcome
Post-conflict and post-error saccade slowing (performance monitoring); non-canceled saccades and target-switch reaction time (response inhibition)

Structured fields used in claim comparison tables when every cited study has a complete layer.

Inspect source passages

Does being better in a second language help you monitor mistakes?

These passages occur verbatim in the stored paper text. They support the points listed below; they do not verify every statement in the explanation.

47 Hindi-English bilinguals took part in Experiment 1

Forty seven Hindi-English bilinguals took part in the study.

22 high and 25 low proficiency participants in Experiment 1

Based on this, participants were assigned to high ( N = 22) and low L2 proficiency group ( N = 25).
Read passages in the original paper

Key findings

In both experiments the high-proficiency group showed more slowing on trials after a stop-and-redirect trial, and proficiency correlated positively with post-conflict and post-error slowing, which the authors read as stronger performance monitoring. The time needed to cancel an eye movement did not differ between groups in either experiment. The low-proficiency group made more failed cancellations in Experiment 1, but this group difference disappeared with the memory-guided task in Experiment 2, suggesting it reflected reflexive glances rather than weaker inhibition.

Methodology

Hindi-English bilingual students were split into high and low English proficiency groups based on whether they attended English- or Hindi-medium schools, with proficiency confirmed by questionnaires, reading tests and a vocabulary test. While an eye tracker recorded their gaze, they looked at a red target but, on some trials, had to cancel that eye movement and look at a second green target instead. Experiment 1 (47 people) used visible targets; Experiment 2 (38 new people) required eye movements to a remembered location, which removes reflexive glances.

Limitations

Proficiency groups were not randomly assigned: school type may carry differences in social background, education or language switching habits beyond English skill, even though IQ and self-reported SES were matched. Samples were small and there was no monolingual group, so the study compares degrees of bilingualism rather than bilinguals versus monolinguals. Interpreting slower responses as better monitoring is an inference, and working memory was not controlled, which the authors flag.

Related papers in this topic

Same topic cluster — not a recommendation engine.