Skip to content
PaperFren

Informed consent

Why is it so hard to judge whether a child can consent?

Hein IM, Troost PW, Broersma A, et al. · BMC medical ethics · 2015

Open access · cc by · source: Europe PMC

We still have no reliable way to tell when a child can give valid medical consent, and the authors argue that systematic measurement, not more theoretical debate, is the way forward.

How this study connects

Role on claims

Each row is a claim on a concept or method page where this paper supports, challenges, or qualifies the statement. Roles are hand-checked — not a model guess.

  • SupportsInformed consentconcept

    We know surprisingly little, empirically, about when children can consent.

    A critical review finds legal consent ages vary widely between countries and look partly arbitrary, and that only two studies had assessed children on all four standard competence criteria; the authors call for a structured multidimensional tool, children aged 7 to 18, and real rather than hypothetical decisions.

    Evidence for the claim as stated.

History

When this study was placed

Dated entries from the concept change log — when this paper was added or removed as support, challenge, or qualifier on a claim.

  1. 2026-09-27

    Placed as supporting evidence on Informed consent

    A critical review finds legal consent ages vary widely between countries and look partly arbitrary, and that only two studies had assessed children on all four standard competence criteria; the authors call for a structured multidimensional tool, children aged 7 to 18, and real rather than hypothetical decisions.

Study at a glance

Design
Other — Argumentative debate paper drawing on legal, developmental and empirical literature to propose a research agenda
N
No participants; a position paper, not a systematic review
Population
Children and adolescents' competence to consent to medical treatment and clinical research
Outcome
Thesis: progress requires standardized empirical assessment of children's competence rather than further purely normative debate

Structured fields used in claim comparison tables when every cited study has a complete layer.

Inspect source passages

Why is it so hard to judge whether a child can consent?

These passages occur verbatim in the stored paper text. They support the points listed below; they do not verify every statement in the explanation.

4 criteria make up the adult reference standard for competence

the generally accepted reference standard for competence assessment by clinicians revolves around four relevant criteria

2 studies had assessed children on all four criteria

only two studies on children’s competence to consent that comprised all four criteria have been conducted
Read passages in the original paper

Key findings

Legal age limits for consent vary widely between countries and look partly arbitrary, since some children below the limit are competent and some above it are not. Development research suggests adolescents gain abstract reasoning but still differ from adults in impulse control and weighing long-term consequences, and that illness experience, parents and peers affect decisions. Only two studies had assessed children on all four standard competence criteria. The authors recommend a structured multidimensional tool like the MacCAT, children from 7 to 18, real rather than hypothetical decisions, varied risk levels, and measures of context and intelligence.

Methodology

The authors examine why the question of children's decision-making competence has stalled, looking in turn at normative and legal aspects, child development, existing empirical data and practical barriers. They then set out recommendations for a research agenda.

Limitations

The paper reports no new data and its literature coverage is not systematic, so its picture of the evidence may be incomplete. It argues that empirical work can break the impasse, but measurement alone cannot settle normative questions such as how much competence should be required for high-risk decisions. The recommendations lean heavily on adult tools, which may not capture what matters for children. It also leaves open whether consent to research should be judged more strictly than consent to treatment.

Related papers in this topic

Same topic cluster — not a recommendation engine.