Skip to content
PaperFren

Did India’s tobacco epidemic peak and recede?

Open paper intelligence

Across NFHS rounds, age-standardized tobacco use in Indian men rose 32% from 1998-99 to 2005-06 (27.90% to 36.81%) then fell 26% by 2015-16 (to 27.31%), while women’s use declined throughout—yet 2015-16 levels still looked like 1998-99, with huge state gaps.

Source

The progression of the tobacco epidemic in India on the national and regional level, 1998-2016

Shaikh R, Janssen F, Vogt T · BMC public health · 2022

doi.org/10.1186/s12889-021-12261-yRead the full paper ↗31 citationscc by

Study at a glance

Design
Cross-sectional — Repeated nationally representative NFHS-2/3/4 household surveys (1998–2016) with age-standardized smoking and smokeless tobacco prevalence for ages 15–49 by sex and state
N
N=601509 · NFHS-4 interviewed 601,509 households (2015-16); NFHS-2 91,196; NFHS-3 109,041; analysis of men and women aged 15–49
Population
Indian men and women aged 15–49 in 27 states and two union territories covering 99% of the population
Outcome
Age-standardized prevalence of any tobacco, smoking, and smokeless tobacco, nationally and by state, 1998–2016

Structured fields used in claim comparison tables when every cited study has a complete layer.

What they did

Used NFHS-2/3/4 (91,196; 109,041; 601,509 households) to age-standardize smoking and smokeless prevalence for ages 15–49 in 27 states and 2 union territories covering 99% of India.

What they found

National use rose then fell for men, declined throughout for women. By 2015-16 male smoking was 12.20% and smokeless 15.12%; female smoking 0.40% and smokeless 2.87%. Male smoking ranged from 5.71% (Maharashtra) to 37.70% (Mizoram).

The limits

What it doesn't show

Repeated cross-sections cannot prove which policies caused the drop; self-report undercounts, ages 15–49 miss older users, and 2015-16 prevalence remaining near 1998-99 warns against declaring the epidemic over.

Key terms

NFHS
National Family Health Survey; nationally representative Indian household survey used in 1998-99, 2005-06, and 2015-16.
Age-standardization
Adjusts prevalence so age-structure changes do not masquerade as tobacco trends.
Smokeless tobacco
Chewed/other non-smoked tobacco; remained more common than smoking among Indian women.
Bidi
Traditional smoked product; part of India’s distinctive epidemic mix versus cigarettes-only models.
Tobacco epidemic
Staged rise and fall of tobacco use; India’s peak and sex pattern differ from the classical Western model.
State variation
2015-16 male smoking 5.71% in Maharashtra vs 37.70% in Mizoram.

Flashcards

1 / 10

Research intelligence for this paper

See its role on concept claims, tensions it is part of, placement history, and related discoveries.

Open paper intelligence

Quiz yourself

1 / 5

Men’s tobacco use from 1998-99 to 2005-06:

Common questions

What happened to men’s prevalence?

Rose 32% to 36.81% then fell 26% to 27.31%.

Largest survey round?

NFHS-4: 601,509 households (98% response).

2015-16 male smoking vs smokeless?

12.20% smoking and 15.12% smokeless.

Biggest geographic contrast cited?

Male smoking 5.71% Maharashtra vs 37.70% Mizoram.

More on Health behaviour